AGE VERIFICATION, CHILD SAFETY, AND PRIVACY: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF MALAYSIA‘S PROPOSED UNDER-16 SOCIAL MEDIABAN
Abstract
The Malaysian Government’s proposal to ban children under sixteen from creating social
media accounts through mandatory electronic Know Your Customer (eKYC) age verification
marks a major shift in how children’s online activities may be regulated. Modelled on
Australia’s minimum-age social media framework, the proposal aims to reduce risks such as
cyberbullying, online grooming, child sexual exploitation, harmful content, and
algorithm-driven harms. While these objectives are important, the proposal also raises
difficult questions about privacy, proportionality, freedom of expression, and children’s place
in the digital world. This article asks whether banning children under sixteen from social
media is really a proportionate response under Malaysian law. It looks at the Child Act 2001,
the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998, the Sexual Offences Against Children Act
2017, and the Personal Data Protection Act 2010 to see whether the law already deals with
many of the risks children face online. It also considers a problem the proposal may create:
mandatory eKYC could require children to hand over even more personal information,
including biometric data, just to prove their age. Drawing on the experiences of Australia and
the United Kingdom, together with the principles of the Convention on the Rights of the
Child, this article argues that although protecting children online is both necessary and
legitimate, a blanket prohibition may restrict children’s digital rights more than is necessary
while introducing new privacy risks. A more balanced approach would focus on
child-centred, risk-based regulation that combines privacy-preserving age assurance, stronger
platform accountability, safety-by-design measures, digital literacy, and graduated access that
reflects children’s evolving capacities. In the long run, protecting children online should not
mean keeping them out of digital spaces altogether, but ensuring those spaces are safer, more
accountable, and better able to respect their rights.
Nicola Erma Harvey, Multimedia University
Hanna Hasanah binti Hafez, Multimedia University

Comments