CHILD SAFETY OR DIGITAL EXCLUSION? TESTING MALAYSIA'S UNDER-SIXTEEN RULE
Updated: Nov 10
Abstract
According to Malaysia's Child Protection Code, social media companies must verify users'
ages and allow only users who are at least 16 years of age to create an account. The move
arises from real worries concerning exploitation, harmful content, and manipulatory nature of
social media. Nevertheless, the move limits children's right to express themselves, access
information, their privacy, equality, and active participation. This article examines whether
the restriction is adequately protective or amounts to excessive exclusion. The article
employs a doctrinal analysis of both the Federal Constitution and the Online Safety Act 2025
while interpreting them in the light of the Child Rights Convention and considering
comparative examples from Australia, the EU, and the UK. According to the article, the
restriction pursues a significantly important objective and is logically connected to the implications of account usage. At the same time, its categorical and identity-related approach
risks missing the minimum impairment requirement and proportionality in general because it
applies to end-users and services with very different risk characteristics, generates privacy
and exclusionary costs, and may lead children to less regulated industries and environments.
For this reason, it suggests that within the framework of Malaysian law, a feature-based
hybrid system should be created. Such a system would include the use of age-banded
accounts, privacy-friendly age verification, limitation on the use of high-risk design elements,
a simple appeals process, a possibility of children’s involvement in the procedure and
independent periodic evaluation of platforms, as well as accountability of platforms in terms
of their operations.
Ang Xin Lin, Multimedia University

Comments