FROM CROWN WARDSHIP TO MODERN COURT: GENUINE SUPPORT OR CONTROL IN DISGUISE? A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF JUVENILE STUDY
Abstract
This essay traces the doctrine governing state intervention in child offending from its origin in
the feudal institution of Crown wardship to its expression in the modern juvenile court, and asks
whether that doctrine, in its contemporary comparative forms, delivers genuine support to the
child in conflict with the law or merely dresses control in the language of welfare. It first
establishes the doctrinal foundations of criminal capacity, centred on the common-law
presumption of doli incapax and its Shari'ah counterpart, before examining whether the cognitive
and social maturity of children raised amid pervasive digital exposure has begun to outpace the
statutory age thresholds those doctrines rely on. A graduated comparison of India, the United
States, the United Kingdom, Germany, and Malaysia then shows that protective statutory
architecture and protective practical outcomes frequently diverge, and that the size of that gap
rather than any single jurisdiction's doctrinal design, is the more reliable predictor of whether a
system controls or supports the children within it. The essay concludes that restorative justice,
properly safeguarded, can narrow that gap, but that the deeper task facing every jurisdiction
examined is not a choice between protection and control but the disciplined, evidence-grounded
recalibration of the specific instruments age thresholds, transfer provisions, remand limits,
funded aftercare through which rehabilitative language is, or is not, translated into rehabilitative practice.
Cheong Yong Xin, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia

Comments