PROPORTIONATE CHILD JUSTICE: BEHIND PARENS PATRIAE
ABSTRACT
The traditional Malaysian juvenile justice system is couched in the language of protection
and rehabilitation. However, its most significant punitive mechanism, detention 'during the
pleasure' of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong or the Ruler under S. 97 of the Child Act 2001,
illustrates how welfare justifications can lead to punitive regulation. This Article contends
that Malaysia should discard the false dichotomy between clemency and retribution.
Proportionate juvenile justice is its founding organising principle: a rights-based approach
that recognises children’s diminished culpability and developmental capacities and right to
participate, while upholding responsible responses to serious harm. The important test is S.
97. Although it abolishes the death sentence for criminals under eighteen, its indefinite and
authoritarian nature raises questions regarding legal clarity, procedural justice, judicial
oversight and transparency. It recommends a five-point legislative agenda: raising the
minimum age of criminal responsibility to at least fourteen, introducing diversion on a
rights-based footing, establishing a specific serious-harm pathway, replacing S. 97 with fixed
and judicially reviewable mandates, and standardising child-sensitive procedural protections.
This approach does not ignore the needs of victims or the safety of the public. Instead, it
places both within a coherent, transparent and just legal framework.
Tarinisha A/P Marimuthu, Brickfields Asia College

Comments