REASSESSING LEGAL AGE-BASED DIGITAL RESTRICTIONS ON SIXTEEN-YEAR OLDS: PROTECTIVE REGULATION OR DISPROPORTIONATE CONSTRAINT?
Abstract
Assume that the greatest threat to children online today is not access to social media but the
notion that exclusion from online environments automatically results in protection of
children. A proposal to ban 16 and below from creating online social media accounts was
recently marked by Malaysia’s mandatory electronic Know Your Customer (eKYC)
verification. This is perhaps one of the country’s most ambitious forays into online safety and
protection of children on the Internet. Inspired by measures adopted and implemented by
other countries such as Australia’s restrictions on the age to access online services, this
proposed measure is designed to prevent children from being exposed to and becoming
victims of online cyberbullying, online exploitation, the adverse effects of algorithms that
could be designed to ‘manipulate’ children online, as well as exposure to objectionable online
content. However, the proposals also raise the very important legal issue of proportionality,
privacy, freedom of expression, the evolving capacity of children, as well as the respective
roles of the State and parents in the protection of children online and the constitutional
boundaries within which the State may act in this regard. This article proposes to critically
examine the proposed framework and to argue that while its intent is to protect children
online, the proposed measures are excessive and would cause disproportionate restrictions on
the online environment of children. The article shall adopt a primarily doctrinal and
comparative approach. In summary, online safety and protection of children online is a
legitimate objective of the State, but such objective should not be interpreted to mean that
children must be excluded from online environments that are increasingly necessary for their
education, communication, creativity and participation in and connection with civic society
and the civic community. Children must be enabled to safely access online environments and
to participate in the same with confidence and dignity. And this is the mark of successful
digital governance. It is not how well children can be kept offline but how well children can
be empowered to participate online safely, confidently and with dignity.
Syahifa Adilah Binti Badhuruzzaman, Multimedia University

Comments