REFORMING MALAYSIA'S JUVENILE JUSTICE FRAMEWORK: BALANCING CHILD PROTECTION AND ACCOUNTABILITY
Updated: Nov 5
Abstract
High-profile criminal cases involving minors have heightened public concern over juvenile
crime in Malaysia. Malaysia’s juvenile justice system is rooted in the doctrine of parens
patriae. The current legal framework governing juveniles in Malaysia comprises the Child
Act 2001, Penal Code, Criminal Procedure Code and Prison Act 1995, which aim to balance
child protection with offender accountability. However, the existing system faces several
limitations. It relies heavily on post-offence interventions while giving insufficient attention
to socio-economic causes, early detection and the neurodevelopmental factors affecting
adolescent decision-making. Furthermore, public discourse is often influenced by penal
populism, which favours punitive measures over rehabilitation. To address these challenges,
this article conducts a comparative analysis of juvenile justice systems in Belgium and
Finland, countries recognised for their strong child protection frameworks. Both jurisdictions
prioritise child welfare, early multi-agency intervention and restorative justice over
retributive punishment. Belgium utilises structured anti-truancy protocols, educational
guidance networks and victim-offender mediation, while Finland adopts the multidisciplinary
“Ankkuri” model to divert young offenders from formal judicial proceedings. This paper
recommends several approaches: raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility from 10
to 14 years; establishing a multi-agency early intervention network involving schools, welfare
officers, health professionals and police; implementing professionally facilitated
victim-offender mediation beyond minor compoundable offences; and reforming moral
education into a project-based, empathy-driven curriculum. In conclusion, this paper argues
that Malaysia’s current legal framework relies heavily on post-offence measures and lacks
sufficient preventive measures. Malaysia should therefore strengthen prevention and adopt
more restorative post-offence measures to better protect juveniles.
Woo Wan Juan, Multimedia University

Comments