THE PROTECTION PARADOX:A CRITICAL EVALUATION OF CHILD PROTECTION ORDERS AND THE LIMITS OF STATE PROTECTION IN MALAYSIA
ABSTRACT
This article critically evaluates the effectiveness of Child Protection Orders (CPOs) in
Malaysia under the Child Act 2001, exploring the meaning of “protection paradox” : the
operational gap between immediate legal rescue mechanisms and the long-term structural
safeguards that are required for child welfare. Utilizing doctrinal legal analysis, judicial
precedents and comparative perspectives from England and Wales, Australia and Singapore,
the study assesses whether the CPOs remain effective as safeguards beyond the point of
immediate removal from harm. The findings suggest that while CPOs successfully provide
emergency rescue, legal adequacy must be re-evaluated to encompass post-order monitoring,
rehabilitation, structured placement, family reunification protocols and proactive
multi-agency oversight.
Fathimah Az-Zahrah Binti Sabri, Universiti Utara Malaysia
Entsar Binti Nasr, Universiti Utara Malaysia

Comments