THE WELFARE PARADOX: RE-EVALUATING THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR JUVENILE JUSTICE IN MALAYSIA
Abstract
This article aims to re-evaluate the Malaysian juvenile justice framework to determine whether
its current mechanisms reflect protection and rehabilitation or a mere tool of penal control. The
analysis focuses on the express and implied tension between state-oriented goals and the reality
of the judicial and administrative practices based on the Child Act 2001 and Malaysia's
obligations under the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). Additionally, the study
identifies critical systemic weaknesses, including a low minimum age of criminal responsibility,
an over-reliance on formal court proceedings, and a tendency toward "over-treatment" through
standardised institutionalisation rather than individualized care. Furthermore, it critiques the
inconsistent application of the "best interests of the child" principle in Malaysian juvenile
sentencing. While Section 83(2) of the Child Act 2001 statutorily mandates that the court must
consider the best interests of the child as a primary consideration in any decision or order,
judicial practice often diverges from this statutory spirit. In practice, Malaysian courts have
frequently given greater weight to retributive and deterrence-based principles, particularly in
cases involving serious offences which thereby marginalising rehabilitative options such as
probation or community service, even when such alternatives are available and appropriate under
the Act. The article also highlights significant "handover gaps" in post-release aftercare, arguing
that discretionary statutory provisions under Section 70 often fail to provide the structured,
actionable support necessary for successful social reintegration. Ultimately, the article advocates
for a holistic reform of the system, calling for the institutionalisation of legislated diversion,
clearer sentencing guidelines, and a comprehensive national aftercare framework to ensure that
"second chances" move beyond rhetorical ideals to become a functional pillar of sustainable
rehabilitation.
Anis Fatheeni binti Muhamad Napiah, Universiti Utara Malaysia

Comments